The potential of ICTs based education in developing countries

Thousands of computers have been deployed over the last 10 years by Computer Aid and our partners into schools and colleges across Africa and Latin America. We have seen students eagerly yet tentatively approach a computer for the first time and quickly develop new skills which allow them to discover knowledge whilst improving their employability and higher education prospects. Our focus and vision should not simply be of ICTs, but of better education delivered through the integration of ICTs in teaching and learning processes. Recently I have been working closely with some of our partners in developing countries and financial donors to understand the role of ICTs in education and how we can facilitate a transformation in the student learning experience. Drawing on research and reports on ICTs in education in developing countries, this post will outline the potential and the shared vision and commitment required to achieve it.

ICTs play an important role in forms of traditional learning. ICTs can enhance traditional teaching of subjects as sources of teaching materials or through the use of multimedia presentations to deliver lectures and classes. Many implementations of ICTs in education focus on equipping both students and teachers with basic IT skills, learning how to use word processors, develop spreadsheets and reply to emails. These skills are vital for individuals to access opportunities in both employment and further education as a number of developing countries integrate ICTs into their wider economic activity. Focusing solely on delivering these basic IT skills or enhancing existing teaching however fails to fulfil the transformational potential ICTs have in shifting the focus of education away from teacher-centred lecture-based instruction to student-centred interactive learning.

The ‘broadcast’ method where the teacher is central as the source of all knowledge is sometimes difficult and tedious, with the emphasis on students reproducing knowledge rather than producing their own knowledge. Becoming passive recipients, students often fail to develop their critical thinking skills. This isn’t to say that the traditional teaching method is without value, as it allows teachers to communicate significant amounts of information to students quickly. Developing students’ cognitive skills to solve real world problems however requires a different approach.

Significant research on theoretical frameworks related to human learning has identified a number of components. Learning is a natural process, with each student learning in a different way. Learn

ing is a social process, through collaboration with other students, teachers and parents. Learning is an active process, requiring the production of knowledge rather than describing pre-existing knowledge. Learning can also sometimes be non-linear, processing different types of information simultaneously. Knowledge must be discovered in order for learners’ minds to form connections of understanding. This requires complementing the traditional broadcast method with the teacher becoming a facilitator of learning. Placing the learner at the centre of the process allows them to draw on a range of resources surrounding them, including teachers, fellow students and peers, collaboration sessions, a plurality of opinions, information resources and technology.

ICTs can transform education from teacher-centred, lecture-based instruction to student-centred, interactive learning environments. There is the potential to transform education and the relatio

nship between students and teachers in a number of ways. By placing students at the centre, ICTs can be used to help individuals discover knowledge through the internet or other multimedia resources. Creating presentations together than enhance collaboration and peer support. Developing and following their own learning strategy can help individuals overcome the particular challenges they face. Material and subjects presented through multimedia and interactive ICTs have also proven to keep students engaged and focused for longer. ICTs can also provide extensive opportunities for the teacher learner relationship to be reversed. Students can become teachers through peer tutoring and reciprocal mentoring, increasing self-esteem, motivation and student engagement. Teachers must be supported to engage with such strategies and not feel ashamed to be taught by young learners or feel concern that they may ‘loose control’ of their classrooms. These potential benefits are particularly appropriate for developing country contexts where schools and teachers often lack resources and deal with large class sizes.

The potential is significant, however such pedagogical integration of ICTs is rarely observed. Key to facilitating this transformation is understanding the current levels of technical and training support provided to teachers, and to identify the level and types of support needed. Learning how to use operating systems, word processors and spreadsheets will enhance existing teaching. Whilst basic ICTs knowledge and skills is a vital first step for teachers and students alike, success will be limited without further training and support for teachers to integrate ICTs in ways which transform their approach to teaching. To achieve this, specific training must aim to introduce teachers to the range of ways in which ICTs can be used to transform education in the way discussed.

I believe this transformation of education driven by ICTs is key to overcoming many of the challenges faced in communities and schools in developing countries. Looking ahead, I will soon be visiting partners to understand how our current work is achieving this transformation, and to better identify the barriers which sometimes prevent this from happening. I hope these visits will inform my future work and direction when building projects and relationships with our partners across the world.

Sion Eryl Jones

Trust Partnerships Officer

How donated PCs are helping pupils in Ecuador

We’ve had some great feedback from one of our partners in Ecuador, the Fondo Ecuatoriano de Cooperacion para el Desarollo (FECD) who have equipped hundreds of schools across Ecuador with computers donated to Computer Aid.

Consuelo Rivadeneira, whose children attend the Angel Héctor Cedeño school in the Manabi province that has received PCs donated to Computer Aid has said:

“Now we can equip schools that never had a computer before and it is very important for children to have IT skills these days. Thanks to this project, the children have an access to technology that we, parents, couldn’t have and I am very happy that they have this opportunity.”

In the past four years, Computer Aid has dispatched more than 4,000 refurbished computers donated by UK organsiations to the FECD in Equador. The PCs have been used to reduce the digital divide that exists in rural areas of Ecuador by providing high quality refurbished computers to schools, colleges and civil society organisations.


Equipping schools with computers means that they can provide lessons in basic IT skills which will give their pupils the opportunity to look for higher income employment in the future. As well as teaching IT skills, the provision of IT in schools can also help improve the lesson content in other subjects as it helps teachers to demonstrate difficult or less interesting subjects in a visual format. With PCs and IT training, many teachers are downloading and using free educational software to support them in teaching key subjects such as maths and languages.

PCs donated to Computer Aid and sent to the FECD has given up to 67,000 students who may otherwise not have access to PCs the opportunity to gain IT skills – which we think is a fantastic result!

Education and Development: the Case for the Transformative Effect of ICTs

In achieving not just universal but high-quality primary education it has become self-evident that ICT has a role to play in teacher training and in the social inclusion in education and employment of people living with disabilities and otherwise marginalised groups.

Aside from the explicit recognition of the importance of education to development articulated in the aims of MDG Two, education in a broader sense, conceived of as human capacity building, is a pivotal ingredient in achieving all of the Millennium Development Goals. Without sustained investment in the training and education of in-service healthcare professionals, for example, progress towards MDGs Four, Five, and Six would stall. Seen in through this prism, ‘Making available the benefits of the new information and communication technologies’ as targeted in MDG-8, has a central part to play in the training and development needed to achieve all of the MDGs.

Developments in the Role of ICT in Education

Beneath the hyperbole surrounding the potential for ICT in development that dominated development discourse preceding the dot com crash, and the equally simplistic backlash that followed, individuals in NGOs, universities and colleges have been quietly introducing ICTs to bring about significant improvement in the quality of teaching and learning.

This means development is not just in the adaptation of ICT applications but a transformation in the pedagogical process. The UNESCO publication ICT in Teacher Education: A Planning Guide documents the transitional stages that teachers go through in ICT adoption from simple application of technology as a substitute for current teaching practice (teachers’ lectures are supported by electronic presentation tools or students are required to write papers using a word processor; and a course syllabus on paper is moved online). As teachers’ knowledge and experience with new technologies continues to develop, and the capacity of the host institution to give support and access to ICT grows, it becomes possible to move beyond the adaptation of ICT applications. The use of ICT in classrooms can lead to a shift towards more learner-centred approaches with spectacular affects on student attainment.

Where my organisation Computer Aid International works in Africa, although much still needs to be done, the accelerating spread of fibre-optic cables and increased private sector competition mean that high-speed broadband is slowly becoming more widespread and affordable. In the institutions we work with we are seeing this transform the application of ICT in education from simple word-processing to the use of video and interactive methodologies and seeing e-learning, applied in the classroom and at home, opening up learning and development opportunities for groups that are traditionally socially marginalised disadvantaged by the limitations of traditional education.

The meteoric rise worldwide of simple, free teaching tools like the khanacademy.org for simple mathematics and English lessons, as well as resources developed specifically to support school based teacher education and training in Africa like tessafrica.net prove the importance now placed on ICT by students and teachers alike.

Overcoming Barriers of Distance, Time and Gender

Kenyatta University, for example, has used a combination of low-cost IT equipment provided by Computer Aid and an online learning environment to extend and improve the quality of its distance learning courses across Kenya. For students, especially those that either have family commitments or are working as teachers, nurses or other roles, this means not having to move to Nairobi to continue study and being able to fit study around work or family commitments. For rural communities this means that the nurses, doctors and teachers that are critical to public service delivery, social cohesion and economic development don’t have to leave to continue their education.

E-learning also reduces the time that it takes teachers and lecturers to prepare for and deliver lectures and assessment exercises. Stella Maris Polytechnic in Monrovia is using the free Open Source e-learning platform Moodle to enable highly skilled people working in government and the private sector to share their knowledge and skills to the next generation through teaching part-time. Computer Aid International has delivered Moodle training to heads of higher education institutions in Kenya, Nigeria and at the e-learning Africa 2010 conference in Zambia.

Education in Rural Development

The work of a Computer Aid International partner in Zambia provides a stark illustration of the impact of ICT in education in a rural context. Working in extremely remote and resource-limited environments in Zambia, Macha Works is driving down the cost of connectivity through the creation of wireless Mesh networks. Using professionally refurbished PCs and wireless routers provided by Computer Aid International, the creation of a rural Mesh network enables hospitals, schools and communities to share bandwidth across a wide area. Sharing a $1,500 per month connection between 50 users is a first step to introducing ICT-enabled education. Students in the local primary school where e-learning has been introduced are passing grade 9 exams in grade 6. Local nurse training schools are attracting new people to the area and outstripping results at neighbouring institutions.

Most importantly, communities with internet access benefit the most by become learning environments: because learning resources are readily available, the most talented young people see opportunities to grow and develop in the area they grow up in and therefore stay to play a role in the development of their communities.

Conclusion

ICT literacy in most parts of the world is as much a prerequisite for employment and learning as basic literacy has been to date. Via the training and professional development of practitioners in all sectors, ICTs are contributing toward the acceleration of all aspects of social and economic development and toward the realisation of all of the MDGs.

At Computer Aid International we believe that tackling problems of widespread affordability and other practical, economic and socially constructed barriers to access is key to ensuring that ICT is a force for equality and mobility rather than a magnifier of existing inequalities. Massive investment in technology is essential across all educational institutions and for training and professional development in every sector of the world economy.

Grand claims for its potential, and expensive and unsustainable pilot projects hurt the reputation of ICT in development but there is now a growing recognition of the need to mainstream ICT across all development programmes. The Social Return on investments in ICT is huge when seen as in investment in the education and continuous development of the people who will make development happen. Mobilising sufficient resources to enable everyone to play their part will require us to ‘develop a global partnership for development’ as stressed in MDG 8. Computer Aid International and its network is one small example of a pro-poor partnership that brings together private companies, donors, government and non-governmental institutions to make ICTs affordable and accessible for the furtherance of the MDGs.

 Stephen Campbell

Director of Finance and Fundraising

Computer Aid International